Have you ever wondered if narcissists genuinely care about their new supply?

If so, you’re not alone. A few of our community members asked about this during a recent support group because they’re going through a discard. 

As a general rule, narcissists do not genuinely care about their new supply because:

  • They can’t form a genuine emotional attachment.
  • They lack empathy.
  • Their need for control overrides genuine care.
  • Their fear of vulnerability prevents deep engagement.
  • They seek admiration instead of genuine connection.
  • They see their new supply as a reflection of themselves.

In this post, I’ll explain each of these to help you understand why narcissists don’t genuinely care about their new supply.

If you have or currently are experiencing narcissistic abuse, visit Unfilteredd’s Institute of Healing from Narcissistic Abuse for help.

They Lack Genuine Emotional Attachment

One reason narcissists don’t genuinely care about the new supply is their inability to form real emotional attachments.1 

Caring about someone means you feel connected to them, and their happiness matters to you. 

For narcissists, relationships are more about serving their own needs and less about mutual affection or deep connection. 

It’s like someone who enjoys a movie only because it entertains them, not because they are interested in the story or characters. 

In the same way, a narcissist values the new supply for the admiration, validation, and services they provide rather than for who they are as a person. 

A narcissist valuing the new supply for the service they provide.

When the new supply no longer serves the narcissist’s needs or starts to demand more than the narcissist wants to give, the narcissist will often disengage without feeling genuine loss or sadness.

Suggested Reading: When Do Narcissists Get Bored with the New Supply?

They Lack Empathy

A fundamental reason narcissists don’t genuinely care about the new supply is their limited capacity for emotional empathy.2 

Empathy is the ability to understand and share the feelings of another. 

For narcissists, their empathy is often cognitive, meaning they might understand on a surface level what someone else is feeling but don’t deeply feel it themselves. 

It’s like knowing that rain makes things wet without feeling the chill of being caught in a downpour. 

Without emotional empathy, a narcissist can recognize that the new supply has needs and emotions but doesn’t truly connect with or prioritize those feelings. 

Their relationship decisions are based on their needs, desires, and how the outcomes affect them personally rather than a mutual exchange of care and understanding.

Suggested Reading: What Do Narcissists Want In a Relationship?

Their Need for Control Overrides Genuine Care

A narcissist’s overwhelming need for control in the relationship often comes at the expense of genuine care and compassion for the new supply.3 

This need for control is similar to a director meticulously dictating every line, movement, and expression in a play, leaving no room for the actors’ creativity or interpretation. 

In the context of a relationship, the narcissist manipulates scenarios to ensure dominance and compliance from the new supply, focusing on maintaining their power and authority above all else. 

This dynamic reduces the relationship to a series of transactions where the new supply’s role is to adhere to the narcissist’s demands and expectations. 

As a result, the narcissist’s actions and decisions are driven by a desire to control rather than by empathy, leading to a relationship that lacks the depth and mutual respect needed for genuine care.

Suggested Reading: 3 Reasons Why Narcissists Are So Controlling?

If you need help with anything related to narcissistic abuse, visit Unfilteredd’s Institute of Healing from Narcissistic Abuse today.

Fear of Vulnerability Prevents Deep Engagement

A narcissist’s deep-seated fear of vulnerability often prevents them from being able to engage genuinely and care deeply for the new supply. 

Vulnerability requires an openness and willingness to share one’s true self, including fears, hopes, and dreams, which is a risk narcissists are unwilling to take.4 

In their relationships, this means narcissists maintain a facade, engaging only at a surface level that ensures their vulnerabilities are hidden. 

A narcissist engaging only at a surface level to hide their vulnerabilities.

Of course, they might offer up selective glimpses into their lives or feelings, but these are often carefully curated to maintain control and avoid genuine emotional exposure. 

Because of this, the relationship lacks the authenticity and mutual vulnerability essential for a deep, caring connection, leaving the new supply feeling disconnected and undervalued.

Suggested Reading: 7 Things Narcissists Fear the Most

Seeking Admiration Instead of Genuine Connection

Narcissists in relationships often seek constant admiration instead of pursuing a genuine emotional connection.5 

This pursuit is like someone who collects art not for the love of the pieces but for the prestige they offer. 

In a similar way, narcissists view their partners as trophies or assets that can boost their ego rather than as individuals with their own thoughts, feelings, and needs. 

They crave the admiration and approval the new supply can provide, focusing solely on how the relationship can serve their self-esteem and validate their superiority. 

A narcissist focusing on how the relationship with the new supply can serve their self-esteem.

This relentless search for admiration leads them to overlook or outright dismiss their partners’ real emotional needs and desires. 

As a result, the relationship becomes unbalanced, with the new supply feeling undervalued and unseen beyond their ability to feed the narcissist’s ego. 

This dynamic prevents the narcissist from genuinely caring about the new supply because they prioritize their need for validation over building a loving, supportive partnership.

Suggested Reading: Why Do Narcissists Want to Be Admired and Praised?

They See the New Supply as a Reflection of Themselves

Narcissists often don’t genuinely care about the new supply because they see them as reflections of themselves rather than an individual with their own thoughts, feelings, emotions, and needs.6 

It’s the same as if someone chose a friend only because that friend always agrees with them and makes them look good in front of others. 

In a relationship, a narcissist focuses on how the other person can make them appear more successful, attractive, or desirable rather than appreciating them for who they truly are. 

This self-focused perspective leaves little room for the narcissist to acknowledge or respond to the new supply’s emotional needs, interests, or well-being. 

Therefore, the supply’s role becomes one of supporting the narcissist’s ego, which demonstrates a lack of genuine care for them as a separate individual with their own feelings and desires.

Suggested Reading: Why Do Narcissists Show Off Their New Supply? (5 Reasons)

If you are ready to be more than a victim of narcissistic abuse, visit Unfilteredd’s Institute of Healing from Narcissistic Abuse today.


Thank you so much for reading; I hope you found this article insightful.

Now, I’d love to hear from you.

Have you observed or experienced how a narcissist behaves with their new supply and noticed a lack of genuine care? 

What patterns or behaviors stood out to you?

Or perhaps you have questions about how to navigate relationships when you suspect narcissistic behaviors are at play.

Either way, let me know by leaving a comment below.

Our Latest Articles

About the Author

Hey, I’m Elijah.

I experienced narcissistic abuse for three years. 

I create these articles to help you understand and validate your experiences.

Thank you for reading, and remember, healing is possible even when it feels impossible.

Unfilteredd has strict sourcing guidelines and only uses high-quality sources to support the facts within our content. You can learn more about how we ensure our content is accurate, actionable, inclusive, and trustworthy by reading our editorial process.

  1. The Attachment Project. How Insecure Attachment Relates to Narcissism. The Attachment Project. https://www.attachmentproject.com/psychology/narcissistic-personality/ ↩︎
  2. Mayo Clinic Staff. (2023. April, 6). Narcissistic personality disorder. Mayo Clinic. https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/narcissistic-personality-disorder/symptoms-causes/syc-20366662 ↩︎
  3. WebMD Editorial Contributors. (2023. March, 30). Narcissism: Symptoms and Signs. WebMD. https://www.webmd.com/mental-health/narcissism-symptoms-signs ↩︎
  4. Marissa Moore. (2022. October, 11). The Good Kind of Vulnerability. Psych Central. https://psychcentral.com/relationships/the-good-kind-of-vulnerability#:~:text=Vulnerability%20is%20being%20open%20but,being%20vulnerable%20requires%20feeling%20safe. ↩︎
  5. Jayne Leonard. (2023. August, 23). Am I narcissistic? How to tell. Medical News Today. https://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/am-i-narcissistic#:~:text=People%20with%20NPD%20have%20a%20deep%20need%20for%20attention%20and,feel%20they%20need%20or%20deserve. ↩︎
  6. Darlene Lancer. (2020. August, 26). Why Narcissists Act the Way They Do. Psychology Today. https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/toxic-relationships/202008/why-narcissists-act-the-way-they-do#:~:text=Narcissists’%20inner%20emptiness%2C%20shame%2C,feelings%2C%20since%20narcissists%20cannot%20empathize. ↩︎

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.